Who doesn’t love a golden and crispy bread with oozing melted cheese as a quick and easy lunch or late-night snack, right? Well, let’s ditch the old stovetop method and learn how to make a perfect, brown, and crispy grilled cheese sandwich in a toaster oven. Also, the toaster oven method would be easier, tidier, and of course, more scrumptious.

What is the perfect cheese for a grilled cheese sandwich?

In order to achieve a “perfect melty cheese”, you can’t just use any cheese in your cheese sandwich, you’ll have to be a little more specific. Here are our top picks!

  • Havarti Cheese: It will provide you with perfect melted and gooey textured cheese.
  • Muenster Cheese: It will melt exquisitely and will provide you with the perfect elasticity.
  • Smoked Gouda Cheese: This cheese will feel like a warm hug to your taste buds.

What Ingredients you will need?

For a standard and basic grilled cheese sandwich you will need:

  • 2 slices of multi-grain bread, or any of your choice.
  • 2 slices of cheese of your own choice.
  • 2 teaspoons of softened butter or low calories mayo

However, if you want a fancy and creative sandwich you can add some extras like fruits preserves, spinach, or some pepper jack cheese to spice things up. Let’s dive into the recipe.

Step by Step Instructions:

Preheating the oven with the baking sheet

To get on with the process, you need to switch your oven on and put it on preheat. Set the temperature around 450 Fahrenheit. incorporate the cooking rack to the lowest possible position because we don’t want extreme heat falling over the sandwich. We do need the heat but preferably from the lower angle. Grab a tray and put a baking sheet on it. Keep the baking sheet on while the oven preheats.

  • The baking sheet will provide aid in making the bread crispy once it is properly heated.
  • All ovens vary in sizes and temperatures, so manage accordingly.

Buttering the slices from either side

Butter acts as a greasing agent in the sandwich and helps make it crispy and binds the ingredients together as well. Moreover, butter gives a very delightful taste and adds value to the sandwich. Grab two slices of bread and put them on a shelve, cutting board, tray or a plate. Grab a knife and swiftly move it in the softened butter and start applying it on the upper sides of the bread slices. Try to use minimum quantity and spread it over simultaneously.

  • Try to use multigrain bread instead of white bread because it white bread has more carbohydrates and it also is very soft and gooey. Multigrain bread gives a good taste and texture altogether. Other bread like Italian and Sesame can be used as well.

Adding Cheese Slices to Bread

Here comes the good part. The cheese is incorporated with butter on opposite sides. Firstly, you select the desired cheese. It can either be mozzarella, cheddar or mixed cheese. Swiss and parmesan also work great for grilled cheese sandwiches. Preferably, hard cheese makes it to most charts. Secondly, the slices should be thick and firm instead of shredded. Shredded cheese melts easily and makes it way out of the sandwich and it looks messy.

  • Take one slice and put cheese on the opposite side of butter.
  • Cover the cheese with the other bread slice and make sure the butter side stays on the upper side

Sandwich Goes in the Oven

Put your oven mitts on before you touch the tray. Put the bread slices on the pan. Pull the hot baking sheet out and place the sandwich on it, then put the tray back in and place it to the lowest position. Close the oven and sit back.

Side by Side grilling

Wait for around 4-5 minutes. Move towards the oven, look for the crispy brown colour if the oven has a transparent glass. If the bread has gained a desirable colour, open the oven and twist the sandwich on the other side. Basically, move the grilled side downwards and put the other side up. Close the oven and sit back for another 4-5 minutes.

Total Crisp and Bind

Keep your oven mitts on and open the oven. Check if the cheese and butter are binding the sandwich completely. Check if both the sides are crispy and brown perfectly. Moreover, look over the edges of the sandwich and see if they look crispy and grilled as well. If everything checks up on the above regards, put the tray out and grab your sandwich with a spatula and place it on a plate.

Cut and Serve

Cut the sandwich in halves with a sharp knife and serve it hot along with your favourite beverages.

Try and leave us feedback!

Can you grill in a toaster oven?

Possible Settings On Your OTG or Toaster Oven

An OTG oven is an electric oven and comes in conventional mode or convection mode (fan assisted) with conventional functions. An OTG can reheat, keep warm, grill/broil, and bake food items.

What is the difference between toasted cheese and grilled cheese?

How do you use a grilled cheese toaster?

In toasted cheese, a slice of cheese is just placed on a toasted pair of bread slices while grilled cheese has the cheese slice grilled smoothly in a griller or simply a pan and then sandwiched between two bread slices.

What can you not put in a toaster oven?

Make perfectly toasted, hot and melty cheese sandwiches in just minutes! Simply place your assembled cheese sandwich in the toasting basket, adjust the dial to your doneness preference, and then toast. The toasting baskets work to hold each sandwich in place while they cook to melty perfection.

Can you use aluminum foil in a toaster oven?

What is good to make in a toaster oven?

After answering those questions about the bakeware in our cabinets here are 4 things I’ll never use in our toaster oven and the reasons why.
  • Glass Bakeware. While there may be companies that say their glass dishes are safe for a toaster oven, the majority do not.
  • Mason Jars.
  • Parchment Paper.
  • Coffee Mugs or Coffee Cups.

Can you cook a pizza in a toaster oven?

From lining pans for easy cleanup to covering casserole dishes during baking, aluminum foil has many uses. Here’s what we know for sure: NEVER cover your crumb tray or the walls of your toaster oven with foil. It can lead to overheating and is a fire hazard.

Can you cook chicken nuggets in a toaster oven?

Step 1 Preheat the toaster oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit using either the bake or convection bake setting. Step 2 Put the pizza or pizza slices onto the rack inside the toaster oven and close the door. Step 3 Bake the pizza for between 5 to 10 minutes. Watch the pizza closely.

Can you cook bacon in a toaster oven?

OVEN & TOASTER OVEN – Do not leave toaster oven unattended while cooking product. HEAT oven to 425°F. BAKE according to chart. LET STAND 2 minutes to complete cooking.

Filling will be very hot. Be cautious on first bite.

Quantity Oven Toaster Oven
40 rolls 13 to 15 minutes Not recommended

Can you cook sausage in a toaster?

TOASTER OVEN: Preheat oven to 425ºF. Place nuggets on toaster oven tray and heat for 10-11 minutes. If frozen, add 2 minutes to heating time.

Can you use a toaster oven like a regular oven?

You absolutely CAN (and should) cook bacon in an oven. Set the temperature to 400°F, and lay the bacon slices (we like thick cut here) flat on a baking sheet or your toaster oven pan. Bake, for about 12-15 minutes, or until the bacon is done to your liking.

What do the settings on a toaster oven mean?

Toaster ovens can tackle meat and sausages as well. And when your sweet tooth acts up, pop a few cookies in them. It’s a sensible alternative to baking a full-size batch.

Is it worth buying a toaster oven?

All things considered, it’s completely feasible to use your toaster oven like a regular oven. However, be sure to keep in mind that not all toaster ovens are cut out for the task. No matter which type of toaster oven you choose, it’s a highly convenient and versatile appliance to own for all types of cooking needs.

Do toaster ovens cause cancer?

The most important thing you need to know about cooking with a toaster oven is that the settings control the heating elements inside your toaster oven. If you have a digital toaster oven, each setting may also provide a preset or suggested cooking time for specific items like cookies or toast.

Is toaster oven bad for health?

Is A Toaster Oven Worth It? For those who cook a lot, a quality toaster oven can definitely make life easier. Small toaster ovens can perfectly brown your morning toast and handle single servings of food, while mid-size toaster ovens can be particularly effective at reheating leftovers and cooking frozen meals.

What company makes the best toaster oven?

HOUSEHOLD electrical appliances may be convenient, but exposure to the electromagnetic fields (EMFs) they generate may not be safe. In fact, such EMFs and those generated by power transmission lines, radars and satellite equipment can even cause cancer, say scientists citing experimental results.

Who makes the best toaster oven?

Are toaster ovens safe? Yes – except for the common danger of burns. Because these little ovens use exposed heating elements, they present no more danger than a traditional oven range, even when turned up.